The thesis critically examines the Rights of Nature paradigm. It challenges the view that Rights of Nature form a unified phenomenon and represent a radical break from Western anthropocentric legal thought. It explores the theoretical foundations, practical applications and limitations of different approaches to Rights of Nature. The main question is whether granting legal personhood to nature or natural entities can lead to meaningful change. The first chapter explores the philosophical and legal foundations of Rights of Nature. It examines how the idea of nature has evolved in Western thought and how ecocentric perspectives emerged in environmental ethics. It then discusses the main theories supporting the recognition of nature as a rights-holder. Particular attention is given to Earth Jurisprudence and Christopher D. Stone's work. The chapter also reviews key developments in different legal systems. It highlights the diversity of legal models and approaches. The second chapter addresses the main theoretical and legal problems raised by Rights of Nature. It examines their compatibility with traditional legal concepts and the risk of rights "inflation". It also explores the tensions within the paradigm. One key issue is the use of an individualistic legal framework to pursue ecocentric goals. Another is the relationship between Rights of Nature and Indigenous worldviews. The chapter highlights the tensions between these perspectives and the risk of imposing Western legal categories on different normative systems. It then challenges the idea of a single Rights of Nature paradigm. Instead, it argues that different theoretical approaches and legal models should be distinguished. The third chapter focuses on Ecuador to assess the effectiveness of Rights of Nature. It examines the political and constitutional context that led to their recognition in the 2008 Constitution. It then analyses the development of constitutional case law and how these rights have been applied. The findings reveal both their potential and the ongoing difficulties of implementation. Overall, this thesis offers a critical assessment of Rights of Nature. It avoids both uncritical enthusiasm and outright rejection. Its aim is to provide a clearer understanding of the different approaches, their underlying tensions and the conditions that shape their effectiveness.
I diritti della natura: "a legal revolution that could save the world"? Una ricostruzione critica di un paradigma plurale
CERESA GASTALDO, FRANCESCA
2026-11-30
Abstract
The thesis critically examines the Rights of Nature paradigm. It challenges the view that Rights of Nature form a unified phenomenon and represent a radical break from Western anthropocentric legal thought. It explores the theoretical foundations, practical applications and limitations of different approaches to Rights of Nature. The main question is whether granting legal personhood to nature or natural entities can lead to meaningful change. The first chapter explores the philosophical and legal foundations of Rights of Nature. It examines how the idea of nature has evolved in Western thought and how ecocentric perspectives emerged in environmental ethics. It then discusses the main theories supporting the recognition of nature as a rights-holder. Particular attention is given to Earth Jurisprudence and Christopher D. Stone's work. The chapter also reviews key developments in different legal systems. It highlights the diversity of legal models and approaches. The second chapter addresses the main theoretical and legal problems raised by Rights of Nature. It examines their compatibility with traditional legal concepts and the risk of rights "inflation". It also explores the tensions within the paradigm. One key issue is the use of an individualistic legal framework to pursue ecocentric goals. Another is the relationship between Rights of Nature and Indigenous worldviews. The chapter highlights the tensions between these perspectives and the risk of imposing Western legal categories on different normative systems. It then challenges the idea of a single Rights of Nature paradigm. Instead, it argues that different theoretical approaches and legal models should be distinguished. The third chapter focuses on Ecuador to assess the effectiveness of Rights of Nature. It examines the political and constitutional context that led to their recognition in the 2008 Constitution. It then analyses the development of constitutional case law and how these rights have been applied. The findings reveal both their potential and the ongoing difficulties of implementation. Overall, this thesis offers a critical assessment of Rights of Nature. It avoids both uncritical enthusiasm and outright rejection. Its aim is to provide a clearer understanding of the different approaches, their underlying tensions and the conditions that shape their effectiveness.I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.



